BYD and Tesla now neck-and-neck for electric-vehicle crown

Article content

So, it’s a straight fight now. BYD versus Tesla. American ingenuity versus Chinese bargain-basement production. Sophisticated cell management versus low-cost battery chemistries. The world’s most charismatic businessman versus the nameless, faceless bureaucracy that is Chinese industry. A nadir has been reached, and pretty much the entire automotive world will be watching how this latest twist in the electrification transition will unfold.

Advertisement 2

Article content

In case you missed it — and depending who you ask and the criteria you set — BYD is either the new king of all EVs or simply breathing down Tesla’s neck. Barron’s, for instance, posits that “BYD Tops Tesla, Takes Global EV Production Crown” and reports that the Chinese company, thanks to an amazing 144,000-unit September, produced some 440,000 battery-powered vehicles in the 3rd quarter, marginally ahead of the 430,488 EVS Tesla built during the same timeframe. Meanwhile, China’s number-one auto news site CarNewsChina reports that “BYD’s BEV sales in Q3 have reached 99% of Tesla’s,” countering that Tesla outsold 435,059 pure BEVS to 431,603 for BYD — an impressive 99.21 per cent of Tesla’s total.

On one hand, the difference would seem the splitting of the tiniest of hairs; on the other, considering Tesla’s erstwhile domination of the global EV market, this is big news. It’s huge news even, especially given that an even closer look to the numbers suggests that momentum, a powerful factor in economic outlooks, favours the burgeoning Chinese giant.

Advertisement 3

Article content

For one, Barron’s reports that BYD’s 440,000 BEVs represent a whopping 67-per-cent year-over-year increase for BYD’s third-quarter. Tesla’s worldwide third-quarter production, on the other hand, was up but a ‘mere’ 18 per cent compared with last year. And while Tesla delivered 1.7 million EVs in the last 12 months compared with ‘just’ 1.3 million for BYD, BYD also sold 136,000 “new energy vehicles” — plug-in hybrids to you and me — in September, bringing its third-quarter total to 824,001 vehicles, which pretty much makes them runaway leaders in plug-in sales. Tesla is hardly in the dog house, but the disruptor is definitely being disrupted.

Recommended from Editorial

Advertisement 4

Article content

What to make of all this?

The biggest losers in this battle of titans, as Motor Mouth detailed three weeks ago, are European automakers. Oh, China is making great inroads into the Russian market, but that’s only because they’re the only country willing to sell cars to Russia. And they are already leaders in Thailand, Brazil, Columbia, and Israel, while BYD is looking to introduce new model ranges in Mexico, Australia and Hungary.

But those are relatively small fry. It is, as I said, the Schengen area that BYD is truly targeting. BYD’s European sales were up some 323 per cent in the first half of this year, reports Barron’s. Oh, Tesla still reigns supreme in overall sales, but, by far, the biggest recent gains have been by BYD and some of its Chinese counterparts. Perhaps more importantly, PriceWaterhouseCoopers expects the E.U. to import some 800,000 Chinese EVs by 2025. Whatever happens in the future, the fact remains that BYD’s surge over the last 12 months has been fuelled by a continued domination of the (surprisingly) still buoyant Chinese EV segment and its invasion of the E.U.

Advertisement 5

Article content

Said invasion has not gone unnoticed. In fact, European governments are racing to bolster their domestic automakers, lest they fall decimated by these low-cost interlopers just as auto manufacturers bear the huge capital investments required to transition to battery power.

Indeed, on the same day that BYD announced its numbers, the Italian government revealed that it is exploring a novel scheme to protect its auto industry. It’s novel because, according to Reuters, the E.U.’s competition rules “do not allow countries to favour local producers.” In other words, no tariffs specific to Chinese automakers are allowed, nor can they — as America is doing with its Inflation Reduction Act – subsidize only those EVs and batteries built locally.

Advertisement 6

Article content

Cars charge at a Tesla super charging station in Arlington, Virginia on August 13, 2021
Cars charge at a Tesla super charging station in Arlington, Virginia on August 13, 2021 Photo by Andrew Caballero-Reynolds /Getty

The workaround, however, is genius. What they will instead incentivize is car purchases that reward low-carbon manufacturing. And as Reuters so assiduously points out, most Chinese production is still fuelled by coal-generated electricity. The cars must also be shipped from China, the fossil-fuelled boats they arrive on also contributing to their carbon footprint.

To be fair, the idea was really France’s, which contends that it is not breaking any rules because, as Reuters points out, “exemptions are allowed for health and environmental reasons.” If these rules prove WTO-complaint and other member of the EU adopt similar incentivization strategies, that would seem to advantage Tesla.

Except that many of the Teslas sold in Europe are built in China, not the good ol’ US of A. The exemptions proposed may not be strictly country-related, but anyone producing their products in coal-dependent China will face significant damage. And, in fact, according to Bloomberg, Tesla is being included in the “Chinese” companies being investigated by the E.U. for unfair trade practices. No wonder then Musk is planning to ramp up production in Berlin.

Advertisement 7

Article content

Depending on how quickly European governments get their protectionist houses in order, that would leave America the most obvious battleground between the two giants. For now, of course, Tesla reigns supreme in North America, the Texas-based giga-giant dominating the American EV segment with an almost 60-per-cent market share; Chinese automakers, BYD included, are not even a blip on its (wind) screen. And with the Inflation Reduction Act’s massive subsidization of domestic-built EVs, the advantage for automakers to produce battery-powered vehicles in the States would seem to be unassailable.

The BYD Seal, foreground, and Seal U
The BYD Seal, foreground, and Seal U Photo by Andrew McCredie

Again, except for the Chinese — or at the very least, it would be close. There’s been little public reckoning of how much less it costs to produce an EV in China versus America, because the threat thus far has remained theoretical. But in Europe, where penetration is already underway, various studies cite an enormous Chinese advantage. Reuters reports that “China has a 10,000-euro cost advantage in small EVs;” Bernstein Research that China “can produce EVs which are 50 per cent cheaper than the West.” Whatever the exact number, it is significant.

Advertisement 8

Article content

Countering this is the IRA — that which President Biden hopes will keep America cost-competitive with China — offering up to US$7,500 to consumers for the purchase of a built-in-U.S.A. EV; the same legislation also offers manufacturers up to $45 per kilowatt-hour to produce said BEV’s batteries domestically. Do the math, and a 100-kilowatt-hour electric vehicle, built in the U.S.A. and powered by domestically produced batteries (and from minerals sourced from Canada, Mexico, or the States) could have about US$12,000 of government money incentivizing it.

That makes Chinese manufacturers — again, led by BYD — seemingly the only country that can take on the Biden’s IRA without building plants here in North America. Indeed, once the Chinese invasion of North America begins, I suspect the key question as to who wins and who loses will be: who do you think can last longer? China’s ability to keep on producing low-cost, low-wage EVs? Or the American government’s ability to dole out hundreds of billions of dollars to shore up local production?

Advertisement 9

Article content

Author’s note: Some will dismiss this discussion as reductivism too far. It may well be. It largely, for instance, ignores factors including established chains of distribution, nativist rejection of otherwise-competitive product, the possibility of further American protectionist policy, and the very real possibility of wage inflation in China. Nonetheless, the monies being bandied about — one country currently enjoying an immense cost advantage, the other throwing around ungodly heaps of taxpayer dollars trying to defend its domestic automakers — are so astronomical that all other criteria would seem largely trivial. Indeed, I really do think that the battle for bragging rights in the EV world reduce to the simple battle between massive subsidization against overwhelming cost advantage. I have no idea who’s going to win this Tesla-versus-BYD tussle, but it sure will be fun to watch.

David Booth picture

David Booth

David Booth is Driving’s senior writer as well as the producer of Driving.ca’s Driving into the Future panels and Motor Mouth podcasts. Having written about everything from the exact benefits of Diamond Like Coating (DLC) on motorcycle camshafts to why Range Rovers are the best vehicles for those suffering from opiod-induced constipation, Booth leaves no stone unturned in his quest for automotive veritas. Besides his long tenure with Driving, he was the editor in chief of Autovision magazine for 25 years and his stories has been published in motorcycle magazines around the world including the United States, England, Germany and Australia.

Education

Graduating from Queen Elizabeth High School in 1973, Booth moved to from his Northern Quebec home town of Sept-Iles — also home to Montreal Canadiens great, Guy Carbonneau, by the way — to Ottawa to study Mechanical Engineering at Carleton University where he wrote a thesis on the then burgeoning technology of anti-lock brakes for motorcycles and spent time researching the also then burgeoning use of water tunnels for aerodynamic testing.

Experience

After three years writing for Cycle Canada magazine and another three working for the then oldest magazine in Canada, Canadian Automotive Trade, Booth, along with current Driving writer, Brian Harper, and then Toronto Star contributor, Alex Law, created an automotive editorial services group that supplied road tests, news and service bulletins to what was then called Southam newspapers. When Southam became Postmedia with its purchase by Conrad Black and the subsequent introduction of the National Post, Booth was asked to start up the then Driver’s Edge section which became, as you might suspect, Driving.ca when Postmedia finally moved into the digital age. In the past 41 tears, Booth has tested well over 500 motorcycles, 1,500 passenger cars and pretty much every significant supercar of the last 30 years. His passion — and, by far, his proudest achievement — however is Motor Mouth, his weekly column that, after some 30 years, remains as incisive and opinionated as ever.

Personal

Booth remains an avid sports enthusiast — that should be read fitness freak — whose favourite activities include punching boxing bags until his hands bleed and running ski hills with as little respect for medial meniscus as 65-year-old knees can bear. His underlying passion, however, remains, after all these years, motorcycles. If he’s not in his garage tinkering with his prized 1983 CB1100RC — or resurrecting another one – he’s riding Italy’s famed Stelvio Pass with his beloved — and much-modified — Suzuki V-strom 1000. Booth has been known to accept the occasional mojito from strangers and the apples of his eye are a certain fellow Driving contributor and his son, Matthew, who is Global Vice-President of something but he’s never quite sure what. He welcomes feedback, criticism and suggestions at [email protected]

Comments

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

POPULAR VEHICLE COMPARISONS

link

By admin